A good cop’s guide to reporting rape

A good cop’s guide to reporting rape

Written by

in

Case No. 9 aired in Pakistan to take drama serial audiences beyond the courtroom for the first time and into police stations, investigations and the ugly conversations that precede a trial for sexual violence. I watched how we, the police, were portrayed. And I had to ask myself the uncomfortable question: Are we really like this?

The courtroom is not only the arena where justice is tested. The first and most decisive battle for the truth begins at the police station.

Watching the show also made me reflect on whether investigations or the public’s understanding of how they are done is more complex than it is?

What actually happens when a survivor of rape approaches the police? What does the law require the police to do? How is an investigation supposed to proceed? What role do medical and forensic evidence play? Most importantly, what does this process look like for a survivor who has to live through it? (For the purposes of this article the focus is on females, but protocols dwell at length on procedures for children and transgender people).

To understand these questions, allow me to distill the complexities and convey the realities of how the system works and how it is supposed to work.

The first information reaching a police station may be recorded in the roznamcha or station diary. This diary provides a chronological record of information received at the police station and of police activity. It is, by itself, the first trace of a complaint received. Where information discloses the commission of a cognizable offence, Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPc) requires that information to be reduced to writing and formally recorded. The law also contains specific safeguards for women reporting cognizable offences, specifically sexual offences, this information has to be recorded by a police officer in the presence of a female police officer, female family member or another person with the complainant’s consent.

The distinction is important.

The roznamcha represents the earliest record of information reaching the police. The FIR formally sets the criminal investigation into motion. What follows is the process of evidence collection by investigation, documentation and presentation of the case in court.

In rape cases, the early stages are significant, biological evidence may deteriorate, CCTV footage may lose its back-up, and clothing and other physical evidence may become unavailable. A medical examination may become indeterminable.

But is a delay in reporting really fatal? No.

One of the most persistent misconceptions is that only a genuine victim reports a rape immediately. Pakistani courts have repeatedly emphasized, however, that survivors may hesitate to go to the police because of trauma, fear, stigma, perceptions of family honour and apprehension of bringing a deeply personal matter into the public domain.

In Mehboob Ahmed vs. the State 1999 (SCMR 1102) the Supreme Court recognized social taboos surrounding sexual offences. In Irfan Ali Sher v. The State (PLD 2020 SC) observed trauma, fear, shame and apprehension regarding a medico-legal examination may explain delayed reporting. The delay may require explanation and assessment but a delay does not determine credibility.

Then there is the question about the interpretation of the sections of rape in criminal law.

What does the law actually call rape?

The Pakistan Penal Code (PPC), 1860 gives a list of crimes and their punishments across a total of 511 sections. Rape is dealt with in Section 375, defined as specified sexual acts committed in circumstances including against a person’s will, without consent or where apparent consent has been obtained through fear, deception, incapacity or other circumstances defined by law.

At the centre of rape’s definition in Pakistan is consent.

The law defines consent as “unequivocal voluntary agreement” communicated through words, gestures, or any form of verbal or non-verbal communications. Courts have held that physical injury is not mandatory. Absence of injuries does not disprove rape. This interpretation helps because many victims do not resist due to fear or coercion.

This distinction matters in investigations because the question is not simply about the presence of physical injuries. The investigation officer is now bound to examine if there was free will, and unequivocal willingness to participate in the act and again whether that willingness was affected by fear, coercion, deception, incapacity or any other circumstance as recognized by Section 375.

Then comes the deal breaker question about medical evidence.

Does medical evidence decide the case?

Medical and forensic evidence can be extremely important, but it is one component of a larger investigation. A medical examination can document injuries, while biological samples and DNA analysis help establish a connection between individuals and evidence. It does contribute to the investigation but is not the mere decisive factor.

For an investigation officer, the principle is straightforward; forensic evidence can strengthen the case, but the case is not wholly dependent on forensic evidence alone. DNA analysis, biological samples and medico-legal findings significantly strengthen an investigation, but their absence does not negate a credible complaint. Courts evaluate the totality of evidence, which includes witness testimony, forensic material, and electronic evidence and surrounding circumstances of the case.

During the course of writing this piece, I interviewed several SSOIUs in-charges across Sindh. Their experiences were deeply reflective and simultaneously profoundly distressing. Yet all of those experiences shared a common message: Sexual offences must be reported and every complaint deserves a thorough and impartial investigation.

One investigator heading an SSOIU in Karachi recounted a case that has remained with her after the investigation concluded long ago. To protect the survivor’s identity, certain details have been withheld. The survivor was a 65-year-old widow who alleged that she had been raped by a much younger male relative. She recalled that her first interaction was not with simply a victim but an elderly woman whose frail physical condition and emotional devastation reflected the impact of the assault.

After the registration of FIR, evidence was secured immediately. Clothing and bedding were taken into custody, biological samples were collected and all samples were sealed and forwarded for forensic examination while maintaining the chain of custody. The subsequent DNA analysis corroborated the physical evidence collected during the investigation.

During the investigation, it was revealed that the motive behind the offence was not sexual desire or any financial dispute. What motivated the young man to rape her was a heated argument between him and his aunt that prompted him to do what he described as, “teaching her a lesson” for trying to school him. The investigator reflected that this case illustrates an uncomfortable reality that she often encounters during investigations of sexual offences; rape is often less about sexual desire than about domination, humiliation and retaliation. It is a brutal exercise of power over another human being.

Another case shared by an SSOIU investigator highlighted one of the most concealed forms of sexual violence: incest and child sexual abuse within the family. A 16-year-old girl was repeatedly sexually assaulted by her father over several months. The abuse continued until the survivor became pregnant. Although her mother and siblings eventually became aware of what had happened, the mother chose silence over her child’s protection.

In another painful recollection of incidents, an SSOIU In-charge narrated a case of a 28-year-old woman, who left home with her brother-in-law and was later confined in a house. During the period of her confinement, she was repeatedly subjected to sexual violence by multiple men. One day she was sexually exploited by a 50-year-old man. This continued for 16 days till she was able to contact her family for help.

When the case was finally registered, all the accused were arrested and later convicted. Yet, the justice remained incomplete; the survivor died during the course of her trial and did not live to see her rapists held accountable.

These are not simple incidents recorded in police registers. These are the stories that lie behind numbers of reported cases—the human experiences concealed within every reported case of rape.

And this is where the numbers begin to matter.

Police data from Sindh provides a troubling picture of reported rape cases:

In 2025, 178 cases were reported across Sindh. During the first seven months of 2026, 132 cases had already been registered. The data tells us that Sindh has recorded almost three-quarters of the number of rape cases registered during the entire previous year. In 2025, Sindh recorded an average of 15 reported cases per month but in 2026 it increased to 19 on average.

Again these figures only give us the picture of only reported cases that reached police stations. The geography of the reported cases tell us, of the 132 cases reported in 2026, Karachi accounted for 44, closely followed by the Hyderabad range at 41. Sukkur range followed with 18 cases, Shaheed Benzirabad with 14, Mirpurkhas with 11 and Larkana range with four.

The district-wise distribution shows us a deeper picture. Karachi’s range 44 cases were unevenly distributed in the zones. South recorded 22 cases, East 12 and West 10. In other words, half of the reported cases came from district South.

The Hyderabad range (41 cases) had a dispersed pattern. Hyderabad district recorded 10 cases, Tando Muhammad Khan and Badin recorded 8 each, Dadu and Sujawal recorded five each.

In the Sukkur range, Khairpur recorded 11 cases, compared with six in Ghotki and one in Sukkur. Shaheed Benazirabad range recorded 14 cases, including eight in Sanghar, four in Nausheroferoz and two in Shaheed Benzirabad. Mirpurkhas Range recorded 11 cases, 5 in Umerkot, four in Tharparkar, and two in Mirpurkhas.

Larkana recorded four cases, while no cases were recorded according to the information from Kamber, Shikarpur, Jacobabad, or Kashmore during the period.

The data becomes more disturbing when you start counting the youngest victims. During seven months of 2026, 23 cases of rape of minor girls were reported across Sindh. A child subjected to sexual violence may face very different barriers to reporting as compared to adults.

The number of such cases registered is only the beginning of the story.

The institutional response to sexual violence is changing. The establishment of SSOIUs pursuant to the framework of Anti-Rape (Investigation and Trial) Act, 2021 represents a remarkable step towards specialized and survivor-centered investigation. The increase in reporting of such cases also reflects an awareness of such specialized mechanisms.

It hardly needs mentioning that there is still a long way to go. But people should know that they can knock on the door of the law. The mechanisms that were created for these very people need to be set into motion with the act of seeking justice. No department can survive if it is not responsive to the needs of its people.

Perhaps, It’s time to question one of the damaging messages women have been given: “Nuqsan sirf aurat ka hota hai.” Undoubtedly, Case No. 09 led to much-needed public debate on sexual violence, institutional responsibility and social attitudes for victims. But the conversation should not be confined to the Sehars of society. It is not about Shafiqs who may represent the failures or responsibilities of the police. It is also about the Manishas as portrayed in the drama who must stand for the truth and condemn what is wrong no matter the cost.

Source: dawn

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *