ISLAMABAD: The Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) has challenged the revised revenue requirement claims of Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited (SNGPL) and Sui Southern Gas Company Limited (SSGCL) for FY 2026-27, urging the Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority (OGRA) to scrutinise billions of rupees in disputed costs before allowing any increase in gas tariffs.
In separate letters to OGRA, FPCCI’s Energy Section has questioned substantial cost adjustments, human resource expenses, financial charges, unaccounted-for-gas (UFG) claims and guaranteed returns on assets sought by the two gas utilities, arguing that consumers should not be burdened with costs that have not been adequately justified or independently verified.
The Federation has also sought an opportunity to present its case before OGRA takes a decision on the companies’ Review Petitions for Estimated Revenue Requirement (RERR) for FY 2026-27.
READ ALSO: Power sector arrears: Upstream supplies at risk as recoveries surge to Rs169.27bn: SNGPL
In the case of SNGPL, FPCCI pointed out that OGRA, in its Determined Estimated Revenue Requirement (DERR), had reduced the company’s claimed net operating cost from Rs 73.016 billion to Rs 47.304 billion, disallowing Rs 25.711 billion. Of this amount, net human resource cost alone accounted for Rs 15.164 billion.
However, the company has now sought Rs 72.657 billion under the same cost head through a pending Motion for Review, which FPCCI argued would effectively restore almost the entire amount previously disallowed by the regulator.
The Federation has asked OGRA to establish whether the grounds for the original disallowance have been substantively addressed before considering any restoration of the amount.
FPCCI has also questioned SNGPL’s requested average prescribed price of Rs 1,712.40 per MMBTU, noting that a prior-year unrecouped shortfall of Rs 491.029 billion alone contributes Rs 159.87 per MMBTU. It has sought an itemised reconciliation explaining how the outstanding balance accumulated.
The Federation has separately objected to Rs 151 million sought for an Executive Induction Programme and Career Progression Trainings, as well as Rs 62 million for a consultancy study on gas losses of SNGPL and SSGC. It maintained that such expenditure should be met from the companies’ administrative budgets rather than passed on to consumers through gas tariffs.
On SNGPL’s connected transmission tariff petition, FPCCI argued that the filing was explicitly based on RERR figures rather than an independent cost study.
It noted that the proposed transmission and distribution tariffs of Rs 73.17 and Rs 424.55 per MMBTU, respectively, incorporate a combined Return on Assets of Rs 51.398 billion even before accounting for the return included in the RERR.
According to FPCCI, this creates the risk of effectively counting the same asset base twice through two simultaneous tariff proceedings.
The Federation has also highlighted SNGPL’s 10.55 percent UFG losses in its distribution system compared with only 0.20 percent in transmission, seeking a time-bound loss-reduction plan as a condition for any tariff relief.
Other concerns include Rs 437 million sought for the LPG Air Mix business against sales of only 30 BBTU, concentration of capital expenditure in distribution and transmission mains, and a Deferred Credit balance of Rs 48.596 million which FPCCI believes should be excluded from the rate base.
FPCCI has further questioned the guaranteed 21.25 percent Return on Assets, arguing that it shields the company from operational risks which consumers are effectively required to absorb through higher prices.
In its separate letter concerning SSGC, the Federation has questioned the company’s presentation of a Rs 1.259 billion surplus, equivalent to Rs 6.73 per MMBTU, for FY 2026-27 without simultaneously accounting for a Rs 69.733 billion shortfall, or Rs 373.48 per MMBTU, claimed in its pending Motion for Review.
FPCCI observed that the latter amount was approximately 55 times larger than the reported surplus and asked OGRA to require SSGC to present both claims together with a consolidated net position.
The Federation has also raised questions about the company’s cost-of-gas assumptions. It noted that crude oil prices declined from US$100.27 to US$97.18 per barrel and the exchange rate improved from Rs 283 to Rs 281, both of which should have reduced costs.
However, the assumed High Sulphur Furnace Oil (HSFO) price increased by 35.7 percent, from USD545.48 to USD740.24 per metric tonne, over the same four months.
FPCCI said this increase had pushed the weighted average cost of gas to Rs 1,285.96 per MMBTU and asked OGRA to independently verify the HSFO price assumption against prevailing market rates.
The Federation has also identified two major cost items in SSGCL’s revised claims which were not included in OGRA’s DERR approved on June 23, 2026.
These include Rs 14.163 billion under financial charges on short-term borrowing, against zero previously allowed, and Rs 20.387 billion as an adjustment for revenue shortfall in Balochistan, also against zero in the earlier determination.
The two items collectively amount to Rs 34.550 billion, representing more than half of the Rs 68.475 billion shortfall now claimed by SSGC.
FPCCI has asked the company to explain why these substantial costs were not reflected in its earlier filing.
On UFG, the Federation has challenged SSGC’s request to pass on Rs 11.444 billion as an adjustment for UFG above benchmark while the company simultaneously earns a return on assets for capital expenditure on projects intended to reduce the same gas losses.
Citing OGRA’s June 23, 2026 determination, FPCCI noted that SSGC’s rehabilitation expenditure claim had increased from Rs 2.023 million in FY 2021-22 to Rs 29.124 billion currently, while the expected reduction in gas losses was still awaited.
It described the substantial increase in expenditure without demonstrated improvement in gas losses as a matter requiring independent scrutiny and urged OGRA to withhold further UFG-related cost pass-throughs until an audit establishes whether previous investments have delivered the intended results.
The Federation has also questioned the escalation in the cost of the Bibi Nani pipeline re-routing project from Rs 2.844 billion to Rs 3.030 billion.
Similarly, the estimated cost of the DR-990 turbine overhaul has increased from Rs 650 million, against which OGRA had allowed Rs 325 million, to Rs 850 million. FPCCI said the revised estimate was based on a single vendor quotation without competing bids.
It has further argued that Rs 83 million sought for rebuilding a boundary wall at SSGC’s HQ-3 facility in Hyderabad should be treated as a repair expense rather than capitalised as an asset.
Another issue highlighted by FPCCI is SSGC’s guaranteed Return on Assets of approximately Rs 33.7 billion, comprising Rs 26.997 billion on natural gas and Rs 6.729 billion on RLNG, which remains unchanged despite the company’s claim of a substantial revenue shortfall.
On gas allocation, the Federation pointed out that supplies to the power sector had increased by 102.5 percent, while supplies to the fertiliser sector had roughly doubled. In contrast, RLNG supplies to captive power plants in Karachi had declined by 8.8 percent and those to general industries in Balochistan by 13.7 percent.
FPCCI objected to the industrial sector being required to cross-subsidise losses associated with Balochistan, arguing that such obligations should be addressed through appropriate fiscal allocations rather than being transferred to other consumer categories.
In both representations, FPCCI has urged OGRA to require SNGPL and SSGC to substantiate disputed expenditure through independently verifiable evidence and subject major cost claims to audit before allowing their recovery from consumers.
The Federation further requested a formal hearing before the regulator decides the two review petitions, maintaining that unsupported costs, excessive returns and persistent operational inefficiencies should not become an additional burden on gas consumers.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2026
Source: brecorder

Leave a Reply