Last month, the Loss and Damage Fund provisionally allocated $21.6 million to Nepal following the August flash floods. That was the first step in the process of disbursing funds, but no money has yet got to the communities that have been affected. Pakistan’s three requests (totalling $58 million) are still unallocated. As described in the public submissions, they relate to agricultural recovery, healthcare in Balochistan, and the recovery of flood-damaged fisheries in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Nothing in any of the submissions is specifically about schools or child protection.
That omission is significant. Climate negotiations are all about money, emissions, infrastructure, and exposed populations. They very rarely take into account what happens to children when adaptation fails. A damaged school is recorded as an infrastructure loss. A child who simply drops out because the school never reopens is effectively lost from the calculation. Malnutrition becomes a health statistic and children who are pushed into work as a result of their families losing their livelihoods become a labour issue. The links between these various outcomes and climate disasters are almost never part of the financial calculation.
Each disaster adds further pressure on families who are already under severe strain from poverty and lack of services. Each delay in recovery makes the next disaster even more difficult to absorb.
Pakistan’s climate commitments make the stakes perfectly clear. Its 3rd Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) is to reduce its projected 2035 emissions by up to 50%, of which only 17 percentage points are unconditional. The other 33 percentage points are conditional on international support. The government has put a cost of $565.7 billion on the programme. At COP31, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif was keen to have grants rather than additional debt and referred to the resilience and adaptation funds as ‘survival funds’.
He’s absolutely right. Survival has to mean more than just the protection of infrastructure and economic assets. It also has to mean the protection of the children whose education, health and security are already being compromised by climate disruption.
The numbers are increasing. The protection is not.
Pakistan didn’t originate the call for tripling of adaptation finance. That was the outcome of COP30 for 2035. Pakistan’s position is that even if you triple the amount from a very low base, the developing world will still be left far short of what they actually need. The developing countries have put forward a baseline of $40 billion which would equate to $120 billion per year by 2035. The developed countries dispute that figure.
But the amount of money raised is only part of the issue. There’s no guarantee that the funds will actually get to the people who are most at risk from the impacts of climate change.
UNICEF placed Pakistan in the group of countries where children faced extremely high levels of climate and environmental risk in 2021. The 2022 floods were a very clear illustration of that. Some 33 million people were affected (some 16 million of them children) and by mid-September at least 528 children had died.
Pakistan simply cannot improve its public services if it is constantly having to borrow to get back on its feet after disasters. Grant-based finance is absolutely essential to maintaining the capacity to adapt.
The damage went on for a long time after the floodwaters had gone. A year on, UNICEF were reporting 30,000 schools damaged or destroyed in a country where one third of the children were already out of school. In the flood-affected districts of Sindh and Balochistan, over 1 in 9 children under five who came to health facilities were found to have severe acute malnutrition.
The 2025 monsoon resulted in over 1,000 deaths and the displacement of over 4 million people. By the end of August there were over 200 child fatalities.
These are not isolated disasters. They are repeated disruptions to the very conditions that children need in order to survive, to learn and to develop. Each disaster adds further pressure on families who are already under severe strain from poverty and lack of services. Each delay in recovery makes the next disaster even more difficult to absorb.
When a flood becomes a childhood crisis
The immediate effects of flooding are fairly well understood. Contaminated water, damaged sanitation and compromised health services all lead to increased exposure of children to disease and malnutrition. Flooded schools are of course a major disruption to education and remove an important source of routine support and protection.
The longer-term consequences are much harder to measure, though of course they can’t be ignored.
A Save the Children survey of 1,200 households affected by the floods found that 25% of parents had sent their children to work following the floods and 4.6% had married off a child. These are self-reported figures and do not represent a national trend, but do highlight the pressures that families are under when their livelihoods are gone.
Official records are of very little comfort. There were just 57 child marriage cases reported in Sindh across the eight districts between 2018 and 2023. That doesn’t in any way give us a true picture of the extent of the practice, particularly given the widespread problem of under-reporting and the existence of informal marriages. There was a provincial inquiry following the reports of ‘monsoon brides’ but again those are just anecdotal reports and not any kind of robust measure of the extent of climate-related child marriage.
The point is that the evidence doesn’t prove that every flood leads to child marriage or child labour. What it does show is that disasters can exacerbate the economic and social pressures which in turn lead to these practices.
Same caution applies with regard to malnutrition. The 2018 National Nutrition Survey in Pakistan found 40.2% of children under five were stunted. No subsequent national survey has established the current level of stunting. It would be wrong to ascribe the entire burden of malnutrition to climate disasters. The lack of up-to-date data is a concern in itself. Pakistan cannot properly assess the impact of recurrent disasters on children’s nutrition without having regular data on their nutritional status.
Research into earlier floods found the educational penalty reduced over the two- to four-year period. The timing and quality of the recovery are therefore critical. Children may well get back to school eventually but the learning that has been lost and the opportunities that have been lost are not simply going to be recovered.
Climate adaptation must reach the classroom
Not all of the climate threats we face are going to come in the form of a flood. Pakistan has 3,044 glacial lakes of which 33 are deemed hazardous and some 7.1 million people are at risk. That doesn’t tell you how many of those at risk are children or how many schools and health facilities are in the path.
Heat is a much clearer example. In 2024, Punjab shut schools a week early due to the heat, getting around 26 million children home. That was a safety measure. The real issue is that so many schools simply aren’t equipped to operate safely in the heat.
School closures are an emergency response. Climate-resilient classrooms are adaptation.
For children, climate resilience is about whether the school is going to be there, whether there’s going to be safe drinking water, whether the health facilities are going to be there and whether the family is going to get sufficient support so that they don’t have to send the kids out to work. Those aren’t secondary social issues. Those are the indicators of whether adaptation is actually working.
Three opportunities for Pakistan
Three international mechanisms provide Pakistan with opportunities to make children’s protection more visible in its climate response.
Firstly, climate finance has to preserve fiscal space. Over 60% of Pakistan’s revenues go towards debt service. Any additional adaptation loans are going to come at the expense of the resources needed to run schools, to maintain health care and to provide social protection. Grants are the way to reduce that pressure. It’s not just an appeal to the heart. Pakistan simply cannot improve its public services if it is constantly having to borrow to get back on its feet after disasters. Grant-based finance is absolutely essential to maintaining the capacity to adapt.
A child’s lost year of education or their exposure to exploitation cannot be captured by the cost of simply replacing a school building.
Secondly, the Global Goal on Adaptation must be about children. At COP30, governments adopted 59 Belém Adaptation Indicators. UNICEF pushed for child-specific indicators and a Lancet study found that of the 5,339 candidate indicators only 23 were child-sensitive. The framework that was adopted does include an indicator on adaptive social protection which is based on the number of children receiving cash benefits. That doesn’t, however, mean that adaptation is being assessed through the lens of children’s education, nutrition, health and protection.
Pakistan’s preference for voluntary, country-led indicators makes it very difficult to reconcile any demands for rigid international reporting obligations with its own stance. The more credible approach is to go domestic: district adaptation plans should report on the number of children reached, the number of schools made climate resilient and the extent to which health and nutrition services are maintained during emergencies. Pakistan’s existing monsoon plan (which provides for temporary learning facilities and mobile health and sanitation services) is a good starting point.
Thirdly, loss and damage finance must take into account non-economic harm. The mandate of the fund is precisely to cover non-economic losses. UNICEF’s research into the 2022 floods identifies the disruption to education, the child protection risks and the loss of access to healthcare as consequences which go well beyond the scope of any conventional economic assessment. A child’s lost year of education or their exposure to exploitation cannot be captured by the cost of simply replacing a school building.
The funding gap is still absolutely massive. The fund got 176 proposals for some $2.8 billion, with just $342 million available at the outset. UNICEF is pushing for a stand-alone COP31 decision on children and a number of countries including Turkmenistan have signed the Antalya declaration. There is no indication that any of those demands have made it into the negotiating texts. Don’t confuse advocacy commitments with actual negotiated outcomes.
Finance without delivery is another form of delay
Pakistan’s own experience shows that securing the finance is not the end of the story. The finance minister has confirmed that some of the international support which came in after 2022 was not utilised simply because the projects weren’t ready.
Pakistan is one of the first five pilot countries under the COP31 Presidency’s BRIDGE initiative (which is aimed at turning national climate plans into finance-ready projects). This is an opportunity to re-think how adaptation priorities are developed and presented.
Project readiness has to mean more than just producing technically sound proposals. School reconstruction has to be done with a view to the realities of flooding and extreme heat. Health investments have to maintain maternal and child health, nutrition and emergency health services. Water and sanitation projects have to be designed to protect children from disease. Child protection systems have to be embedded into disaster preparedness rather than simply being activated when harm has already occurred.
Results must also be measured in terms of the children reached and services sustained rather than simply the amount of money spent or the amount of infrastructure constructed.
Pakistanis are absolutely right to argue that a country which is responsible for a relatively small proportion of global emissions should not be expected to go on borrowing indefinitely to survive a crisis which it didn’t in any way create. Getting international finance is only the first stage of the responsibility.
Pakistan is asking the international community to acknowledge that climate inaction has a human cost and it will be up to them to demonstrate that at home. The real test of COP31 is not going to be another financial commitment (though that will be there too) but rather whether that commitment actually helps to ensure that children don’t have to be forced to give up their education, their health, their safety and their childhood every time the monsoon comes.
Climate finance which can’t protect the child is not a complete adaptation strategy. A recovery that leaves the child behind is not resilience.
The article does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Business Recorder or its owners.
Source: brecorder

Leave a Reply