ATIR takes notice of fake adjournment granted by FBR official

ATIR takes notice of fake adjournment granted by FBR official

Written by

in

ISLAMABAD: In an unprecedented matter, Multan Bench of Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue (ATIR) has taken judicial notice where the assessing officer granted a fake adjournment of thirty days in order to circumvent limitation of adjudication. Landmark judgement requiring the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) FBR to streamline the record keeping of adjudication proceeding has been authored by the bench comprising on Khurram Shahbaz Butt and Naveed Zafar Khan.

The backgrounds facts are that Muhammad Imran Ghazi, counsel of the appellant taxpayer argued before the ATIR that impugned order is time barred as adjournment of thirty days mentioned in the order was never claimed by the taxpayer. On that the ATIR required the concerned officer to appear in person with record.

The ATIR observed that “Perusal of the order sheet maintained in the adjudication record revealed that on 20.11.2025 the officer had recorded that “Mr. Muhammad Amir, Partner of firm attended the office proceeding and made request that case may be adjourned for thirty days. The same is granted.”

Whereas before ATIR an affidavit sworn by Aamer Tufail Warraich, son of Muhammad Tufail Warraich, the Managing Partner of the appellant firm, was produced.

Wherein it was solemnly affirmed that the statement recorded in the impugned order regarding attendance and adjournment on 20.11.2025 was incorrect and contrary to the record; that neither he nor any partner, employee or authorised representative of the RP had made any oral or written request for adjournment on 20.11.2025 or signed any document or order sheet for that purpose.

On that the ATIR required the assessing officer to file counter affidavit indicating the consequences of not providing the same. The assessing officer has not provided the counter affidavit and the ATIR held that since no adjournment was actually sought therefore assessment order passed after 180 days of issuance of show cause notice is time barred.

The ATIR observed that “we consider it necessary to observe that the maintenance of a true and contemporaneous order sheet is the foundation of fair adjudication, and an entry which extends the period of limitation to the detriment of a taxpayer demands the highest degree of care and integrity.” The ATIR has sent copy of the order to the Chief Commissioner Inland Revenue “for information and such action as may be deemed appropriate in accordance with law.”

When asked for comments Shahid Jami, tax consultant observed newly appointed members of the ATIR having vast experience in tax laws are a blessing for the taxpayers across the country as now fair judgements are forthcoming frequently setting new precedents which are also being upheld by Superior Courts.

Jami added “let’s see whether any action is taken by the Chairman FBR against such assessing officer who tempered official record to cover up their inefficiency in four cases identified by the ATIR.

Copyright Business Recorder, 2026

Source: brecorder

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *