The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) has clarified that the Peshawar High Court (PHC) can continue hearing constitutional petitions under Article 199 of the Constitution, except cases relating to detentions under governor’s rule and the Maintenance of Public Order (MPO) Ordinance in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Aaj News reported on Monday.
A two-member bench, headed by Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and comprising Justice Amir Farooq, issued the clarification while hearing a case concerning the PHC’s jurisdiction following the imposition of emergency and governor’s rule in the province.
The bench explained that its November 5 order restricting the high court’s proceedings applied only to cases concerning governor’s rule and arrests made under the MPO Ordinance.
During the hearing, PTI Chairman Barrister Gohar Ali Khan argued that the FCC’s earlier order had halted the hearing of constitutional petitions at the PHC, affecting litigants as well as the professional activities of lawyers.
The bench clarified that the restriction was limited to matters involving detention under governor’s rule and the MPO, adding that the PHC could hear other petitions under Article 199.
Article 199 empowers high courts to review actions taken by public authorities, enforce fundamental rights and examine the legality of a person’s detention.
Barrister Gohar also urged the court to extend judicial relief to political workers and leaders detained under Section 3 of the MPO Ordinance, arguing that they had no effective legal remedy.
He pointed out that a review board had not yet been constituted in the province to examine detention cases and said steps were also needed regarding people held at police lines.
The Khyber Pakhtunkhwa advocate general told the court that a review board would be formed after the completion of the three-month period, after which cases of individuals detained beyond that period could be referred to it.
Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan observed that several miscellaneous applications had been filed at the FCC’s Peshawar registry and would be considered when placed before the bench. He said that, apart from the application filed by the bar council, the other applications had not yet been fixed for hearing.
The court allowed the bar council to become a party to the case, observing that the matter concerning the emergency was an important constitutional issue and required the involvement of bar councils.
The bench subsequently adjourned further proceedings for an indefinite period.
In a post on social media platform X after the hearing, Barrister Gohar said he had asked the court to allow the PHC to hear petitions challenging the emergency and governor’s rule, as well as cases seeking the recovery of detained leaders.
He said the November 5 order had also affected constitutional petitions concerning the chief minister, speaker of the provincial assembly and other lawmakers. He argued that denying people detained under the MPO access to bail and judicial hearings violated their fundamental rights.
Background
The legal dispute emerged after President Asif Ali Zardari approved the imposition of emergency and governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa on October 11, on the federal government’s recommendation. The armed forces were also deployed under Article 245 of the Constitution to assist the civil administration in maintaining law and order.
The PTI challenged the constitutional validity of these measures before the PHC on October 14, seeking the restoration of the elected provincial government.
The high court had reserved its verdict on the petitions. However, on November 5, the FCC ordered a halt to proceedings on Article 199 petitions filed on or after October 12, citing the invocation of Article 245.
Following that order, the PHC’s administrative committee suspended hearings on the affected petitions and directed that new petitions be returned.
The FCC’s latest clarification allows the PHC to resume hearing other constitutional cases, while the restrictions concerning governor’s rule and MPO-related detentions remain in place.
Source: brecorder

Leave a Reply